Saturday, January 26, 2019
What Is it that makes Armstrongism SO appealing to those who support it?
It's a valid question.
What is it exactly, that makes Armstrongism SO appealing to those who fully embrace it's completely flawed ideologies? What is it about Armstrongism that has caused people to completely deny reality in their quest for truth and understanding?
Despite the full brunt of historical evidence which is a free and open library for the browsing, Armstrongist supporters wear blindfolds and earplugs in the face of such dramatic affronts to their concepts and mindless imaginations. Despite the full brunt of hardships and assaults on rightful living, and despite the full brunt of even half-ways intelligent rebuttals to some of their most easily dis-proven theological embarrassments, they continue to relish in the madness of constant deceptions and continual delusion. They do not believe it is deception, nor do they believe it is delusion. To them, it's reality - even though clearly, and without any legitimate dispute, it is anything but reality. It is clearly, and unarguably, complete non-sense - made up by one man, with one vision, and one dream, fueled by vanity, ego, conceit, and power.
With that framework clear - what is it, then, that makes Armstrongism SO appealing to those who support it? It is the clear embracing of the concepts and imaginative dreaming of exactly the mindsets of the one who started it all. Namely, vanity, ego, conceit, and power.
Armstrongism is a fairy tale land of make-believe for many who did not, in real life, achieve, attain, or grasp the lifelong dreams of authority they may have wanted in their human lives to that point. For others, it was an avenue to create within that very structure the very embodiment of real power, using ego, and vanity, and conceit to achieve just such.
For others, traditional religion had, for one reason, or another, burnt them severely - whether it was Catholicism, or Protestantism, or any other form of organized religion which had shown itself, to them, as a fully evident fraudulent system - Armstrongism provided bucketfuls of theories as to why Corporate Christianity was as untruthful as they had observed it to be. With stories of abuse and freshly laid paths that all led to evil and paganism from within their horror stories of Corporate Christianity past, they were more than eager to embrace a different, seemingly refreshing concept of what they took to be a new light of truth.
This new light of truth, in fact - was the spark that all of these people began to fully indoctrinate within themselves, regardless of what exactly their specific reason was. Their leader, Herbert Armstrong, or whichever splinter leader they bought into later on down the road - spoke with enough convincing argument and authority that - when juxtaposed against the lies they had bought in the past, simply seemed to make sense and were appealing to minds that rejected what they thought was correct in the first place. Perhaps, in previous experiences, they experienced the abusive Southern Baptist Pastor, or the deviant Catholic Priest. Perhaps, in previous experiences, they remember the commercialism of secular Christmases, or the perceived emptiness they may have felt chasing Easter eggs on Easter morning. Or, perhaps, they simply were not taught the tenets of actual, authentic, Christianity - instead trapped in a televangelist-oriented, money-abusing system bent on money, authority, and power - and fled it, only to be attracted to the exact same system by someone else who told them they, well, were not after their money, and were not, initially, believing the system was about money, authority, and power. In short - they were duped once, then were duped again.
In a majority of so many of these cases was one common characteristic that was embraced. The idea that what was before was wrong - so what is now must be right.
And you have to admit, from the surface - in the worldview that it was in the 20th Century - it seemed right. It certainly did seem right! Technology - the space age - in fact, the nuclear age - made a convincing argument to Herbert's theories. The rapid rise of Armstrongism and growth led a sense of credibility to the argument. It's hard to argue when your emotions are completely overtaxed with 14,000 other people who are believing what you believe, and are of the same mindset! If they are right, and you are right - well then, it must be right, and that's that, right?
And that - right there - was the seed and the trap that made it all appealing. Here's a new and different way of living and thinking that opened up new doors to a whole new world of opportunity. But with all of the available opportunities and traditions were the acceptance of unquestioned and unchecked power from those in charge of the system they were embracing. The kicker that said "I'm in" The belief that down the road, in just a few years - is the absolute assurance that Herbert's ideas were true - including you being a part of a World Rulership where you, yourself, would be one of those in the King's Inner Circle, ruling and governing in - you guessed it - authority, luxury - and power - right back to square one.
The only thing is?
Herbert's ideas were not true. They were lies. They were built on financial greed and empirical lust. They were built on irrational concepts of racism and superiority. They were built on worldly business models, with the capstone worldly treasures that would make the top rich and powerful in their world, and the poor impoverished and shackled. The promises of a Utopian government in 3 to 5 years were false. The promises of interpretations of prophecies were also just as false. The ideas of the majority of the ministers were - you guessed it - false. In fact, Herbert's empire was just as scandalous, just as abusive, just as divisive, and just as greedy as anything you'd find in what they came from in the first place. The end result was disappointment, disillusionment, and a deep hunger for facts without the emotional and/or spiritual concepts that hurt them so much in the first place. And what was created? Dysfunction, Distrust - and in many cases, agnosticism and atheism. And in most cases? Anxiety, depression, trauma - to name just a few behavioral issues that were born from the cesspool of Armstrong's Atrocities.
Bringing it back around to the original question. What is it then, NOW, that makes Armstrongism SO appealing to those who support it - despite all of the above, or the reasons, and what not?
It can only be one thing. And it's best described summarily in just five words.
It is, what it is.
Their entire lives, full extended families, decades of memories, and a host of other entrenched webs are simply worth more than what it would be to start new. So, even though there are other more appealing options that look available despite the disgust of the deceit they plainly see, not changing anything would be, to them - a greater risk of collapsing their entire life's structure than it would be to leave the structure and build new. In other words - they fear it would all collapse on them before they get out to start new.
Thus, the appeal the remains, honestly - in totality - is for many - rooted in just ONE word.
Survival.
Labels:
Armstrongism,
Banned By HWA,
CCOG,
Church of God,
COG,
Cults,
Herbert Armstrong,
LCG,
PCG,
RCG,
Religion,
UCG
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Since you equated WCG to a marketing program, I have started to see not only their tactics, but also the tactics of other marketing programs designed to lure you in with free information, and then sell you expensive, exclusive services.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very successful way of making money, because the people who are good at this are very rich.
Exactly. That's the secret they did not want you to know! And once you catch on to their methodologies (which they tried very hard through information control to hide), everything falls into place.
ReplyDeleteSurvival is probably as good a word as any to describe the reason for those in the COGs to hang on to beliefs they dare not look into.
ReplyDeleteYet, for many in the “less abusive” COGs such as UCG and particularly COGWA, it is seemingly not so bad to them. Using COGWA as an example, the hub of their power and social network is Dallas. Here you have a thriving economy and a church congregation filled with ministers’ kids or relatives and many past students from Ambassador College. These comprise those rewarded by the WCG. They have family and friend ties that must not be broken as it is their history and much of the basis for which they live.
They cannot or will not see the doctrinal weaknesses of or hurts others share about the WCG because “everything went so well for me.” It works for them because they were able to self select friends from a wider group of many tens of thousands in WCG days, but will this work for their kids as they select friends and spouses from a few thousand and just a handful of people their own age.
Will it work for these Gen Xers themselves in a few years when the likes of COGWA and UCG start retiring the older ministers on salary and replace them with people that have a bit more years left than Xers who might be in their 50s. Will these Xers think these selected 28-38 year-olds are their spiritual leaders? Will this cause a problem? More splits? History says yes, but the COG mindset will endure.
Many of these COGs do not teach doctrine anymore. Instead, they talk about enduring to the end, discerning, shutting down heresy and wolves in sheep clothing (which is simply when someone studies and disagrees, even respectfully). They count on members remembering the old teachings which sounded reasonable way back when they had no other religious teaching to balance the COG teaching with.
It is easier to attack the “evil” of disagreement than it is to logically teach their beliefs because if the UCG and COGWA leadership did teach the basis for their beliefs, members might start noticing the holes in the logic. They might see that much is not based on logic, but rather on the “revelation” given to Herbert W Armstrong. Which is dangerous, because then members might look into the past and sins of HWA.
But, this too might not make a dent in the hold the COGs have on their members as the ministry still seems comfortable touting the name of HWA and people still seem unaware of HWA’s troubling sins. And while I thought SURVIVAL was an excellent word to explain why members of the COGs stay in the COGs, the inability to dent or crack their COG mindset can perhaps be best blamed on PROGRAMMING. Of course, if the programming is changed they may well indeed not survive, and that kind of death is gain (dying to the old man), as they can then live in Christ.
"They cannot or will not see the doctrinal weaknesses of or hurts others share about the WCG because “everything went so well for me.”"
ReplyDeleteThe Elite Club mindset, the PK culture club, so to speak. The word here is "disconnected" from the general COG experience. It's the "upper class" of the Church who is blind to the realities that a majority of those who were in the Church experienced. They don't understand because they haven't experienced it - therefore, they probably consider themselves "blessed".
These are the ones that are not capable in many cases of seeing their own pride or callous arrogance. They live in a made-up bubble of misinformation and any dose of reality is ignored for their own pleasures, IMO.
I recall back in WCG days that it was acknowledged on occasion that the levitical priesthood was replaced by the order of Melchizadek. Not sure why the fact that the order of Melchizadek consisting of only CHrist didn't register for me, but as I recall the WCG mainly used it to support tithing and not much else. The splinter COGs are now saying that they are the ministers of Melchizadek and are thus of that order. Disgusting. Do you recall WWCG claiming that their ministers are of the Melchizadek order or are the splinter COGs taking that a step further?
ReplyDeleteHey I sent you an email a couple weeks ago and tried sending one now. Are those going through? Blessings...
ReplyDeleteI don't see it - they should go through. Let me double check my inbox.
ReplyDeleteI don't see it. I'm going to investigate further. What date did you send it?
ReplyDeleteI just started reading Marion McNair's book (free online now) - he describes HWA's marketing in detail. Was this one of your sources?
ReplyDeleteI used to think all these former ministers had fallen away - now I realize their eyes were opened.
The answer is simple - it is great knowing everything. It is great having no doubts.
ReplyDeleteBut once you breach the fortress, it starts crumbling - slow at first, then more rapidly.
Since email doesn't seem to work, I'll say here that I hope you are doing well and that you are in my prayers.
ReplyDeleteHi SHT - are you okay? Have not read anything from you here or at Banned for quite a while.
ReplyDeleteApologies - a family member had an emergency and my time has been consumed. Will try to get back into it soon!
ReplyDeleteNo apologies needed! Just wondering if you were ok.
ReplyDeleteHope your family member is doing ok.